Newsroom: 320-363-2540  ·  record@csbsju.edu
Collegeville & St. Joseph, MN 52°F · High Level Clouds
Latest
SJU football receives bye, hosts second round of nationals  •  Jordan Modjeski selected for Division III Emerging Elite Program  •  Ptanyetu Powwow hosted at St. Ben’s  •  CSB+SJU serves trademark lawsuit  •  Honoring the Bennies and Johnnies who have served in the armed forces  •  A heartfelt invitation  •  “Alone In A Crowded Line”  •  The hypocrisy of AI on our campus  •  SJU football receives bye, hosts second round of nationals  •  Jordan Modjeski selected for Division III Emerging Elite Program  •  Ptanyetu Powwow hosted at St. Ben’s  •  CSB+SJU serves trademark lawsuit  •  Honoring the Bennies and Johnnies who have served in the armed forces  •  A heartfelt invitation  •  “Alone In A Crowded Line”  •  The hypocrisy of AI on our campus
Opinion

The hypocrisy of AI on our campus

The other day, I was scrolling on my phone when a post appeared in my feed that read: “Being accused of using AI on an

By Margaret Heroux · · Updated · 3 min read

The other day, I was scrolling on my phone when a post appeared in my feed that read: “Being accused of using AI on an assignment you completed yourself is the modern-day equivalent of a witch accusation.” The thought stuck with me. I have loved writing since I was a kid. Although writing essays for class is no one’s favorite activity, I have always enjoyed reading books, learning new words and writing stories in my free time. You might think professors would encourage that passion now that I’m in college. Instead, I find myself “dumbing down” my vocabulary or deliberately leaving spelling and grammar mistakes in my work to avoid being accused of using AI. Professors are increasingly monitoring students’ AI use, yet students who have never used it are still accused, while some who do use it slip under the radar. Meanwhile, no one seems to be monitoring how much professors are beginning to rely on AI to teach. 

As an education student who hopes to become a teacher, I recognize that AI can be useful for things like lesson brainstorming or grading, but I’m already seeing it go too far. In one class, our professor handed out a packet of questions and practice problems for us to work through in groups, a common classroom activity. As my partner and I read it, we realized that much of the handout didn’t make sense. It was professionally formatted and filled with academic language, but the closer we looked, the less coherent it became. It reminded me of a sci-fi movie character rattling off something like, “To bypass the core mainframe, we need to reroute the auxiliary lexicon to stabilize the quantum projector before the antimatter containment field collapses.” It sounds convincing at a glance, but falls apart under basic scrutiny. When we asked the professor, they admitted it was AI generated. This was not the first time this has happened. 

This reliance on AI content points to a big double standard on campus. We as students pay a great deal to pursue an education, so using AI to cheat our way through makes little sense. Faculty, in turn, are paid to provide that education. Teaching and thoughtfully designing courses are crucial parts of their work, so it makes little sense for them to rely on AI to do those tasks for them. A common defense is, “I’m just using AI as a tool to make things easier.” But when does a tool become a crutch? If the slides, assignments, syllabuses and course materials are all designed by AI, what meaningful role remains for the teacher? The issue is not whether instructors use AI at all, but whether it replaces the expertise, judgment and engagement students are paying to learn from. 

I’m paying for these classes and my professors’ knowledge so I can learn, grow and succeed in my career. That feels like a worthwhile investment. But I don’t want to pay to sit in a room while someone reads aloud from AI-generated slides. If I can get the same education by asking ChatGPT, what am I paying for? I believe our professors at CSB+SJU have knowledge and expertise to share, and I believe my education here is valuable. I just hope that if students show we still care, our university will commit to using AI in ways that support, rather than replace, effective teaching.